Comparison with Industrial Formats and Fonts
DXF is a general-purpose design data exchange format, but in manufacturing sites and design fields, other 2D formats specialized for specific uses (Gerber, G-code, font data, etc.) are also used together. This explains the differences between these formats and DXF, and notes for conversion.
1. DXF vs Gerber Data (Gerber / RS-274X)
Gerber data is the industry standard format for printed circuit board (PCB) manufacturing.
| Feature | DXF | Gerber (RS-274X) |
|---|---|---|
| Main Use | Mechanical design, general 2D/3D drawings | PCB patterns, masks, silk printing |
| Structure | Vector geometry (lines, arcs, polylines) | "Flash" and "draw" via apertures |
| Layer Meaning | Designer's arbitrary classification (outline, dimensions, etc.) | Directly linked to manufacturing process (surface copper, resist, drilling) |
| Coordinate System | Arbitrary (WCS/OCS) | Absolute board coordinates (usually inches or mm) |
Conversion Notes
- Polarity: Gerber has concepts of "positive (draw)" and "negative (remove)" but DXF does not.
- Fill Handling: When converting DXF
HATCHor thickPOLYLINEto Gerber, "fill" processing needs to be performed to paths that board manufacturing machines can understand.
2. DXF vs G-code (G-code / RS-274)
G-code is a numerical control (NC) language for controlling CNC machine tools and 3D printers.
| Feature | DXF | G-code |
|---|---|---|
| Role | "Design Data" (what to draw) | "Machining Commands" (how to move) |
| Content | Shape definitions (start point, end point, radius, etc.) | Sequential execution of coordinate movement, spindle rotation, coolant ON/OFF, etc. |
| Abstraction Level | High (geometric entities) | Low (movement paths after tool radius compensation) |
| Compatibility | Common in many CAD | Has dialects for each machine (controller) |
Workflow Relationship
Usually processed in the flow: CAD (DXF) → CAM (Conversion) → NC (G-code). CAM software reads DXF and generates G-code considering tool thickness and cutting speed.
3. DXF vs Font Data (TTF / OTF / SHX)
Text data is one of the most problematic areas in CAD.
| Format | Type | Handling in CAD |
|---|---|---|
| TTF / OTF | Outline Font | Common to Windows/Mac. Displayed as Bezier curves in CAD. |
| SHX | Stroke Font | AutoCAD-specific format. Composed only of lines (strokes). |
| DXF (Exploded) | Geometric Shapes | Fonts "exploded" into line segments and arcs. |
Text Traps in CAD
- "Text" or "Shape": When sending to machines (laser cutters, etc.), text entities (
TEXT,MTEXT) in DXF are often ignored. - Solution: Need to "outline (explode)" fonts into geometric shapes.
- Missing SHX Fonts: When opening DXF containing SHX in software other than AutoCAD, fonts may be replaced with standard fonts, causing text positions and sizes to go wrong.
4. Other Related Formats
HPGL / PLT (Hewlett-Packard Graphics Language)
- Use: Plotters (large printers) and old cutting machines.
- Features: Very simple command format composed of pen up/down (
PU,PD) and movement (PA). A format closer to machine control than DXF.
PDF (Vector PDF)
- Use: Drawing distribution and viewing.
- Comparison: PDF can also hold vector data internally, but accurately restoring layer information or CAD-like geometric attributes (like circle radius) is difficult.
5. Which Format Should You Choose?
| Purpose | Recommended Format | Reason |
|---|---|---|
| Mechanical Design/Data Exchange | DXF | Supported by most CAD and has high precision. |
| Board Manufacturing (PCB) | Gerber (RS-274X) | Board factories' manufacturing lines assume this format. |
| Direct Machine Control | G-code | The only language that machine controllers can interpret. |
| Graphic Design | SVG / AI | Good at handling colors, gradients, Bezier curves. |
Related: DXF vs SVG | DXF vs DWG | G-code Overview and Versioning